Cymraeg
Welsh 
Home
Snowdonia
Green Key
Partnership
Freedom to choose - Snowdonia Group
What We Think
Addresses
Questionnaires
Search
Your Support
Observation 78: Are they listening?

"Park Insists it has taken on board vehement opposition to Green Key scheme, Snowdonia is listening" - The North Wales Weekly News, March 7, 2002.

Johanna Firbank reports on a conference that looked ahead to the Snowdonia National Park's next 50 years


Lessons have been learned from the storm of opposition sparked by the proposed Snowdonia park and ride scheme, says the Snowdonia National Park Authority (SNPA).

Chief executive Iwan Huws said he was astonished by the strength of feeling that hit his desk daily - and the desk of the transport minister in Cardiff.

The Authority has been shocked by the vociferous opposition of many traders and residents expressed at a series of public meetings in January intended to sell the Green Key scheme to local people.

Mr Huws was speaking at a conference, Snowdonia National Park: The next 50 Years, organised by the Snowdonia Society to mark the 50th anniversary of the park.

He said that the Green Key partnership, which includes Gwynedd and Conwy County Councils, the Welsh Tourist Board and the Welsh Development Agency, would issue a public statement in April.

The Green Key scheme proposed park-and-ride gateways at Llanrwst, Betws-y-Coed and other towns, where motorists would leave their cars and transfer to a network of buses.

Mr Huws hinted that the partnership may now backtrack on some of the Green Key scheme's more contentious proposals.

"Only allowing two hours parking within the Snowdonia National Park is extremely controversial," he admitted.

"We should get the public transport system improved first before we try and get people onto buses." .......


Are they listening? Do the last two sentences quoted above inspire confidence that they are?

That Mr. Huws is "astonished by the strength of feeling" speaks volumes.  It demonstrates how insular the Snowdonia National Park is; they obviously  do not know or understand the needs of the local economy, residents,  and  visitors.

Despite the overwhelming rejection of the Snowdonia Green Key Scheme at public meetings, expressed by people in letters, e-mails, phone calls and on this web site Mr. Huws is still intending to "try and get people on buses".

Common sense should have told him that a two hour parking limit within the National Park would be controversial.


We note from the Snowdonia National Park's Annual Report for 2000-2001 the following (our italics)

  • Traffic and Transport Aims:

    • To increase the accessibility to and around the National Park and to decrease the negative impact of traffic on the environment and communities of the National Park.

  • Traffic and Transport objectives: 

    • To develop a strategic framework and partnership to achieve the above aims.

    • To achieve a modal shift from private car to public transport, cycling and walking.

    • To increase awareness of opportunities for alternative transport choices.

    • To improve the adequacy and quality of alternatives to private car travel.

Whilst the objective of achieving a modal shift from private car to public transport remains, park and ride in various guises will be actively promoted.

To us the word 'alternative' in this context means choice of mode of transport.  However, It would seem to us that the modal shift objective has greater priority than the promotion of alternatives - the Green Key scheme sought to compel the transfer from car to bus by restricting and removing parking facilities in the park.


The SNPA Chairman, in his introduction to the  Annual Report, wrote that the foot and mouth epidemic 

Had a disastrous effect on communities and it soon became clear how closely the agricultural and tourism industries were inter-related. One cannot flourish without the other.

We are concerned at the number of people who responded to the Park and Ride proposals by saying that if they are implemented they will visit less often or not at all.  The effect of people not coming to the Park is now clearly demonstrated and hopefully the lesson has been learned.  We must now do all we can to respond to visitor needs and welcome them back.


 Next Observation

Back